a maman et ses passions pour le Taoisme



 
 

Taoism

  • What is the Tao?
  • Can we study the Tao?
  • What is the difference between Confucianism and Taoism?
  • Why was Lao Tzu the honored master of Confucius?
  • What did Confucius think of the Tao?
  • My favourite quotes about Confucius
  • Some Taoism-related resources
  • Zhuang Tzu, the Butterfly philosopher

  •  

     
     

    What is the Tao?
    Tao means "Way of Life". We are all manifestations of the Tao. However, the true Tao is above words and beyond description. It is something that can only be experienced, not understood through normal intellectual understanding. Lao Tzu (approx 500 BC), the founder of Taoism,  says: "Tao can be talked about, but not the Eternal Tao".

    The Tao originally manifested itself as the Wu Chi, or the great undiferentiated origin of all things. It then divided into Yin and Yang. The Tao is complete and has room for all - good, bad, great, small, perverse, sacred, profound, simple. The above circular Yin Yang figure represents the balance of opposites in the universe.
     

    Can we study the Tao?
    The Taoist thinkers would say that we can. This is not a type of practice with techniques and goals; instead, we can learn to relax into the course of events, and we become more aware of our place in those events (while paradoxically becoming less aware of ourselves as being separate from the events themselves). As we discover ourselves within the Tao, we find a type of inner guidance. But Confucius had some good reasons to think that this practice is not so feasible.

    Abstraction
                          Lao Tzu
    When beauty is abstracted
    Then ugliness has been implied;
    When good is abstracted
    Then evil has been implied.

    ...

    The sage experiences without abstraction,
    And accomplishes without action;
    He accepts the ebb and flow of things,
    Nurtures them, but does not own them,
    And lives, but does not dwell.
    [tr Peter A. Mere]


    Perhaps a good way to understand Taoism is to compare it with Confucianism since most ideas of Confucius are counter to Taoism. Confucianism is concerned primarily with the needs of society, and unlike Taoism, not the ability of a person to live in harmony with nature. Lao Tzu felt that simplicity of the heart would lead to balanced manners and rituals. But conservative Confucius felt that humanity needed to be trained and controlled through strict observation of social rules. Confucianism is a guide to morality and good government. Confucius stated that the ideal person was one of good moral character. The ideal person was also truly reverent in worship and sincerely respected his father (humm, mother was not mentioned) and his ruler; so when these types of people were rulers, their moral example would inspire the people to lead good lives.

    What is the difference between Confucianism and Taoism?
    Roughly, it's like the difference between an "authoritative" government and a "laissez-faire" one. Lao Tzu is held to be Confucius' real adversary. But it is more accurate to say that the essential difference is the difference between Lao Tzu's direct way to the Tao and Confucius' detour by way of the human order:
    "Confucius represents the classical, Lao Tzu the romantic,
    Confucius stresses social responsibility, Lao Tzu praises spontaneity and naturalness,
    Confucius'  focus is on the human, Lao Tzu's on what transcends the human,
    Confucius roams within society, Lao Tzu wanders beyond."
     

    Lao Tzu and Confucius
    According to tradition Lao Tzu was the honored master of Confucius. Legendary or true, it is told that Confucius, impressed by Lao Tzu's influence on people, visited him once to ask advice, ironically enough, on points of ceremonial etiquettes. It is also said that during the meeting the founders of two influential yet contradictory philosophies never got around to discussing their conflicting ideas. Lao Tzu was annoyed that Confucius came to the meeting dressed in his most formal and elaborate robe, as well as by Confucius' interest in the past.
    "The men of whom you speak are long since dead and their bones are turned to ashes in their graves."
    Confucius tried to explain his belief that new knowledge must be based upon old knowledge. Lao Tzu interrupted him saying:
    "Put away your polite airs and your vain display of fine robes. The wise man does not display his treasures to those he does not know. And he cannot learn justice from the Ancients."
     "Why not?" asked Confucius.
    "The swan does not need to bathe daily to remain white" was the answer of Lao Tzu. And he abruptly ended the interview.
    Confucius went off and said to his disciples: "I know that birds can fly and fish can swim and beasts can run. Snares can be set for things that run, nets for those that swim and arrows for whatever flies. But who knows how Dragons ride the wind and cloud up into the sky. Today I saw Lao Tzu. What a Dragon!'"
     

    What did Confucius think of the Tao?

  • "I know why the Tao is not practiced. The intelligent go beyond it and the dull do not reach it. I know why the Tao is not manifested. The 'good' go beyond it and the unworthy do not reach it. There is no one who does not eat or drink, but there are few who really have 'taste.'"
  • "If I can hear the Tao in the morning, in the evening I can die content."
  • "The human being manifests the Tao. The Tao doesn't manifest the human being."

  • My favourite quotes about Confucius
    "I admire Confucius. He was the first man who did not receive a divine inspiration." Voltaire
    "The study of the Confucian philosophy is of greater profit than that of Greek."  Ezra Pound
    "Superior and alone, Confucius stood
    Who taught that useful science -- to be good." Alexander Pope
    "I haven't ever refused to teach anyone who made at least token payment." The Master Confucius
     

    Some Taoism-related resources
    Taoism and Anarchism
    Stories from Chinese Classic Literatures
     
     
     



     
     
     

    Zhuang Tzu (Chuang Tse) 

    Zhuang Tzu is my favorite philosopher (and some say that he may well never have existed). Along with Lao Tzu, he is one of the most influential Taoist thinkers. Zhuang Tzu was not just following Lao Tzu's perspectives - he refined and made them transcendental, and to me he's the most attractive and intriguing Taoist figure.

    "How can we be sure of what we are seeing?" or the issue the interchangibility of appearance and reality was one of his main interests, and Zhuang Tzu thinks that much of the meaning of the world is bound up in apparent contradictions.

    Butterfly philosopher One day about sunset, Zhuang Tzu dozed off and dreamed that he turned into a butterfly. He flapped his wings and sure  enough he was a butterfly...  What a joyful feeling as he fluttered about, he completely  forgot that he was Zhuang Tzu.  Soon though, he realized that proud butterfly was really Zhuang Tzu who dreamed he was a butterfly, or was it a butterfly  who dreamed he was Zhuang Tzu! [tr. Brian Bruya]
    Between Tzu and the butterfly there must be some distinction, but one may be the other.
    Zhuang Tzu also says "enjoying life is just a delusion"!!!

    The fable told by Zhuang Tzu that I like most is about two people who were trying to create seven apertures for an emperor who had been deprived of them, made him die. This is the Zhuang Tzu philosophy of "doing through not doing".

    His mystical style contributes to the tendency to treat him as an irrationalist. But his fantasy was also intended to talk down to rational Confucius.

    Zhuang Tzu's Story of Three Friends

    There were three friends discussing life. One said:  "Can we live together and know nothing of it, work together and produce nothing? Can people fly around in space and still forget to exist. World without end?"
    The three friends looked at each other and burst out laughing. They had no explanation. Thus they were better friends than before. Then one friend died. Confucius sent a disciple to help the other two chant the traditional funeral ritual. His disciple found that one of them had composed a song. While the other played the lute, they sang:
                                  "Hey, Sung Hu! Where'd you go?
                                    You have gone where you were before.
                                    And we are here -  Damn it! We are here!"
    Then the disciple of Confucius burst in on them and exclaimed: "May I inquire where in the funeral ritual it allows you to sing so irreverently in the presence of the departed?". The two friends looked at each other, smiled, and said: "Well trained in liturgy, but the poor fellow doesn't understand life and death!"


    If you want to read more philosophical fantasy of Zhuang Tzu.